Yet I just sat there stoically.
Stunned.
Confused.
Frozen in indecision.
I couldn’t explain why, but it felt oddly comfortable to have a cock resting in my mouth.
“Go ahead, Gregor,” Scott said. “Suck my cock.”
I didn’t obey.
Or rather I didn’t obey at first.
I couldn’t believe I had a cock in my mouth.
I couldn’t believe it when I felt myself beginning to bob.
“There you go, cock sucker,” Scott groaned, making my red cheeks burn even redder… the term cock sucker not one I’d ever imagined being applied to me. Yet… yet… I was suddenly consumed with a surreal urge to start sucking.
As I’ve mentioned, I’d never considered sucking a cock… not even once… yet now that I unexpectedly had one in my mouth, I felt an immediate desire to suck it.
“Oh yeah, we’ve just found our replacement for you, Halpert,” Anderson said, as I ever so slowly bobbed on Scott’s cock… which felt so hard, warm and comfortable inside my mouth.
“I told you guys he’d be a perfect freeuse faggot for us,” Scott bragged, as he pulled me off the couch and onto the floor on my knees… his cock slipping free.
Being called a cock sucker… and a freeuse faggot… and hearing Anderson inferring this would become an ongoing thing, I knew I needed to slam on the brakes before things went any further. I could probably justify what had already transpired as a brief moment of weakness, or that my brain had been shocked into inaction, or that Scott had forced his dick into my mouth… which he had… but I couldn’t explain away the thirty seconds or so I’d willingly sucked his cock.
In desperation I blurted out, “Scott, I can’t do this!”
“Oh fuck,” Halpert moaned. I turned my head towards the sound and saw that Halpert was now on all fours on the couch, and Anderson was buttfucking him… making my eyes go wide.
“Of course you can! You’re a cock sucker, Gregor,” Scott told me, slapping my face with his cock.
“I’m not,” I said, shaking my head.
“Then why did you suck my cock?”
“You shoved it in my mouth,” I pointed out, oddly not getting off my knees.
“But once it was there, did I make you start sucking?”
“I-I-I don’t know why I did that,” I stammered, busted by the accusation, and unable to explain why I did that… not even to myself.
“It’s because you’re a born cock sucker,” he said, sliding his cock back in my mouth.
Again I had his cock in my mouth.
Again I had a choice to make.
Again my body betrayed me as, after a brief hesitation, I resumed bobbing.
“Oh fuck, fuck my ass,” Halpert moaned, sounding like he was really enjoying bottoming … another activity I’d never even remotely considered. Mary often said the ass was an exit only hole, although I don’t know why, since I’d never fucked an ass, and I hadn’t ever brought up the subject to her.
“Think he’ll become our bottom bitch too?” Anderson asked, as I slowly sucked Scott’s cock.
“Yeah, soon he’ll be our two-hole cum bucket,” Scott asserted confidently… and the only thing more shocking than my sucking Scott’s cock was his opinion that I’d take it in the ass.
“Yeah, I was worried we wouldn’t find a new freeuse faggot for another month or so,” Anderson said.
“I told you I’d take care of it,” Scott said as I kept sucking his dick… taking just over three inches into my mouth… sucking his dick tentatively, since I didn’t really know what I was doing.
I mean sucking a dick wasn’t a particularly complex activity… just keep your teeth out of the way while you bob back and forth… yet I couldn’t fathom possibly taking more than half of his massive dick in my mouth. Mine was just under five inches, and although Mary could deep throat me, she seldom did.
“Yeah, you can recruit bitches and faggots like Brady can throw touchdowns,” Anderson said.
“Oh God, Anderson, harder, destroy my pussy with that cock,” Halpert begged and moaned like a bitch in heat.
“You’ll soon be saying that too, Gregor,” Scott said, as he clutched both sides of my head and began pumping most of his cock in my mouth… making me gag.
He pulled out, saliva dripping down my chin as he ordered, “Focus on breathing through your nose while I face fuck you, faggot.”
I tried to reply, but I was muzzled by his cock sliding back into my mouth.
“Now get sucking, Gregor,” Scott ordered, half of his cock in my mouth.
Yet again I’d had a momentary opportunity to do something besides suck.
Yet again I hadn’t taken it.
Instead I began bobbing… feeling a weird compulsion to obey him… a desire to suck… which made no sense. I’d never been curious about sucking cock… hadn’t ever even dwelled momentarily upon the thought before today… yet here I was… sucking my much younger neighbor’s cock while right next to me another guy was getting ass fucked.
“Oh yeah, I knew you’d be the perfect replacement for Halpert,” Scott said, as I slowly bobbed.
“Oh fuck,” Halpert moaned loudly, not sounding at all manly.
I bobbed for a couple minutes… but then I heard the front door open.
I froze!
“Don’t you dare stop sucking, cock sucker,” Halpert ordered, as he pumped his entire cock in my mouth, making me gag again.
Oddly, I heard myself apologizing as I resumed sucking.
“Shit, I see you found a new faggot,” a very deep voice said… and this one sounded very manly, although I couldn’t see him past my mouthful of dick.
“Yeah, and he’s a raw virgin,” Scott said, sounding totally confident while my cock raged.
“Shit,” the man said. “So he’s got a virgin pussy?”
“Yep, plus he hasn’t even tasted his first load yet,” Scott said as he resumed fucking my face.
“Poor fellah! We’d better do something about that,” the man said.
“Yes, and I think I can help him out in another half a minute,” Scott promised. He then furiously fucked my mouth, and in just a dozen more strokes he warned, “Any moment now,” before he erupted into my mouth, growling, “Oh yes! Swallow it, cock sucker.”
I had no choice as he held my head and deposited his load into my mouth and down my throat… which… which… which made me come in my pants.
I swallowed his load… feeling a surreal rush of ecstasy at being used so roughly, and it excited me enough to prompt a no-touch orgasm.
“Oh fuck,” Scott groaned as he pumped his load into me. Thankfully, since I was on my knees, no one could tell I’d come from being used like a cock sucking girl.
“My turn to shoot a load,” Anderson said, and he came over to me as Scott pulled out.
Before I could say anything… which I really wanted to do, since his cock had just been in Halpert’s ass… an entirely new level of perverse humiliation for me… he shoved his cock in my mouth.
Mindlessly… now intoxicated by cock… I bobbed on Anderson… ignoring the gross reality that I was sucking a cock just in another man’s ass. Yet to my surprise, other than a little tangy, it didn’t taste gross at all.
“I got his pussy first,” the new man said.
“Sure, Bobby,” Scott said as I bobbed on another cock. “I’ll get the lube.”
“Yeah, this bitch is about to start moaning like an eighteen-year-old slut,” Bobby (the man with the deep voice) said with a confidence that scared me.
Anderson said, sensing my fear, “Don’t worry. After you start getting dicks in your pussy, you’ll never get enough of them.”
“Just like you constantly crave a dick in your mouth,” Scott added.
I shook my head sideways even though I kept sucking… which was a rather weak protest.
“Maybe he’d rather just remain a cock sucker,” Scott said.
“That really isn’t an option,” Bobby said.
“True, true,” Scott agreed as I bobbed on Anderson’ cock.
Anderson grunted a few seconds later and deposited his load in my mouth… this time I smoothly kept sucking and swallowing… feeling a complete sense of surreal satisfaction at sucking a cock to completion and swallowing its load… my cock still rock hard, even after I’d come in my pants.
“Halpert, prep your replacement,” Scott instructed.
“Yes, Master,” Halpert said, a word that enhanced the hierarchy I was suddenly part of.
“Stand up,” Scott said, as Anderson pulled his cock out of my mouth… the aftertaste of his cum lingering.
I did, sheepishly, my knees sore after being on them for a good fifteen minutes.