The trio in the college choose trio over anything – 01

“Amen!” Zoe added.

We played a couple of games and then watched a movie. I know that may not sound like much of a party to some people, but I had fun. The alcohol helped.

“You know,” Zoe said to me at one point. “I’m surprised you never asked one of us out on a date.”

“Yeah,” Skylar agreed. “You made it plain that you don’t think of us as sisters.”

“And your teasing makes it pretty obvious that you’re attracted to us,” Zoe added.

“So why haven’t you asked?”  sky prompted.

“Three reasons really,” I shrugged. “First, neither of you ever act in a way that would make me think you were remotely interested. You take my teasing good naturedly enough, but if I hear one more ‘Don’t even think about it’ about it, or ‘In your dreams’…” They looked at each other and giggled as I tried to ape their tones as well as their words.

“Maybe, being the nice girls we are, we were just trying to play hard to get?”  the sky grinned.

“Second,” I said, trying hard not to react to her words. “I like the way our friendship works. I wouldn’t want to do anything to ruin that.”

“Especially with us planning to live together next year!” Zoe agreed.

“Is that the big reason?” Mo asked. I looked at her and grinned.

“Not really,” I said. “I think I would have at least tried to get one of you to date me despite everything.”

“Then why haven’t you?” Zoe asked, looking honestly curious. I hid my grin admirably.

“The truth is,” I sighed melodramatically. “There is no way I could possibly choose between you two. I pine for both of you in my dreams.”

“Oh brother!” Zoe groaned.

“Putting it on a little thick, aren’t you?”  sky asked rhetorically.

“What, you don’t believe me?” I asked, trying to sound wounded.

“No,” Zoe smiled. “But it’s a shame. I’m betting now you probably would have gotten lucky with one of us.”

“I could always flip a coin and see what happens?” I offered.

“Don’t even think about it!” Skylar laughed.

“In your dreams,” Zoe added.

“See what I mean?” I asked, letting my voice sound annoyed.

The truth was that I was a little annoyed. Would I have asked one of them out if I thought I had a chance? I’d like to think not, but my mind was working hard at the moment trying to figure out who I would have asked. It really wasn’t an easy question!

Skylar’s breasts were enough to draw any guy’s attention, and Zoe’s impish smile and tight ass got to me in ways I didn’t like to think about! Zoe was prettier, but Skylar was easier to talk to in some ways, and did I mention she had big tits? Yeah, yeah, I know, a typical guy.

“Made up your mind yet?” Skylar asked, looking at me oddly.

“I wish you were serious,” I joked.

“How do you know I’m not?” she asked. I looked at her and couldn’t tell. I was sorely tempted to pick one of them and see what would happen, but I just couldn’t do that to the other one.

“I just can’t do it,” I sighed loudly.

“It’s a good thing,” Zoe grinned. ” The sky would have been so hurt when you chose me.”

“You?” Skylar said in disbelief. “There is no way he would have picked you over me!”

“Give me one good reason why he wouldn’t!” Zoe demanded.

“I can give you two!”  sky snapped in reply.

“You know,” I sighed loudly. “It’s times like this that I wish this room had a mud wrestling pit.”

“Who needs one?”  Sky said, and then looked at Zoe with an evil grin. The curly haired girl nodded. The next thing I knew, two pillows came out of the darkness and struck me.