That Will not Occur Again – 2

“And it was wonderful too!” Alice said, grinning back at her sister as she fondled me. In a split second of time, the situation had gone from Twilight Zone to Body Snatching. I honestly began to wonder if some time during the night aliens hadn’t come down and taken over the twin’s bodies, none of this was making any sense. Or I wasn’t anyway as I stood there feeling my cock beginning to stiffen though my mind was reeling with the explosion I had anticipated hearing, which never came.

“Here, sit down, drink your coffee. I think we need to talk,” Shane said.

**

Two weeks had passed. I lay there on my bed looking up at the ceiling in my room remembering that moment. At first confused, I’d become angry, hearing how they had so easily duped me. My emotions, affections seemingly toyed with, played with, just as they’d done to me in the physical sense. I was furious with the two of them, though I’d eventually ranted and raved long enough that I once again sat back down exhausted. Only then did they calmly tell me the why of it, in hopes I’d eventually understand.

The biggest surprise coming when I learned it was Alice and not Shane who actually had the white little birthmark. That was the beginning. I then learned how they had actually taken turns, every other evening, or every other date, switching roles so that I had actually been seeing and dating the two of them together, and not just Shane as I would have sworn I had been doing. That Shane had given Alice our secret password right from the start was another.

She had known it all along. The girls had gone on to explain to me that it had always been that way between the two of them. Being so close as I now knew they would always be. They told me how they would meet someone, and then how they would date him together, secretly without his ever knowing.

Always comparing notes at the end of the evening so that they were informed as to what had happened, where they’d gone, what they’d done so that there would be no slip ups when they traded identities. I guess I should have been suspicious to some degree when I never saw Alice with any other guy the entire time I was dating Shane, or actually both rather. But it just never dawned on me that she wasn’t.

It was hard to take, to understand hearing it. Again, it had initially made no sense, and it hadn’t helped much when they informed me I was only the third guy that they’d actually had sex with. So it wasn’t like they were doing that for their twisted pleasures either, though I certainly hadn’t seen it that way.

They had gone on to tell me that if one of them for whatever reason didn’t find attraction in the person they’d begun dating, then by agreement, they both broke it off. And in every case, the poor unknowing individual would never learn he’d actually been seeing both girls, on and off, just as I had done.

That they had both ended up liking me didn’t make any of this any easier to accept, nor understand. I had ended up sleeping with Shane as opposed to Alice. Their deception in that being they had wanted to test my own loyalty towards them in a sense. In a very twisted sense the way I saw it.

They also played by another set of interesting rules too. Whichever sister first found the guy that one of them felt they might both be interested in getting to know better, it was she that if and when the time came, would be the one to actually initiate actual sex between the two of them. The other…as in my case, was free to enjoy anything short of that. Then, also as had happened to me, they’d do the switch, using the birthmark ploy as a means for testing that person’s loyalty and devotion to one sister over the other.

I had perhaps passed the test. But I had felt used, deceived and betrayed upon learning that.

They had both left shortly thereafter, understanding my need to be alone and think about what they’d done to me. I don’t know how many times I thought about the various dates, activities and things we’d ALL done with one another. And in all that time, I had never figured it out, never saw any differences that would have alerted me, or even remotely hinted at the fact that I was actually seeing and dating the two of them simultaneously.